
1. GENERAL
The principle of legality is set out in Article 18(1) of the Federal Constitutional Law (B-VG):
„All public administration must be exercised solely in accordance with the law.“
The term „the entire public administration“ refers not only to the administration of the federal government, the state or the local authorities, but also to that of self-governing bodies (e.g. the Chamber of Commerce, the Bar Association, the Medical Association).
Only the administration is explicitly mentioned as part of the executive branch. It goes without saying, however, that the judiciary is also bound by the law; the principle of legality therefore applies to the courts as well. All judgements or rulings must be based on a legal foundation. The fact that the judiciary was not specifically mentioned, or rather that the legislature explicitly referred only to the administration, can be explained historically. At the time the Federal Constitutional Act (B-VG) was drafted, it was already taken for granted that the principle of legality applied to the judiciary. However, this was not yet so clear with regard to the administration’s obligation to comply with the law („the responsive nature of the Constitution“).
The principle of legality is an essential component of the fundamental principle of the rule of law. It follows, therefore, that should this principle be amended or abolished, this would constitute a comprehensive amendment to the Federal Constitution, which would require a referendum (Article 44(3) of the Federal Constitutional Act).
Article 18(1) of the Federal Constitutional Law (B-VG) establishes an objective obligation to ensure that the administration and the judiciary act in accordance with the law – a subjective right cannot therefore be derived from it.
Whether the principle of legality applies „only“ to the exercise of sovereign power or also to the administration of the private sector is a matter of debate („differentiated principle of legality“). The prevailing view, however, is now that Article 18(1) of the Federal Constitutional Law (B-VG) is binding solely on the exercise of sovereign power. In our view, this is also correct – if the State acts in the sphere of private-sector administration, it is, in principle (though see the so-called „fiscal application of fundamental rights“), to be treated in the same way as a private individual. If the state is also to be bound by (specific) statutory provisions in the field of private-sector administration, such provisions must be enacted (e.g. public procurement law).
According to legal doctrine, in certain areas of law, „final programming“ is sufficient; this means that a statutory definition of the administration’s objectives is deemed to be adequate. This is recognised in particular for those areas where specific regulation is not possible from the outset. This is the case, for example, in spatial planning law, where the specific use of land cannot be regulated at the statutory level – here, only objectives are laid down. One example is the Tyrolean Spatial Planning Act 2022 (LGBl 43/2022, as amended by LGBl 51/2026), Section 1(2) of which sets out the following „objectives“:
„lit a) the economical and appropriate use of land,
lit b) the protection and care of the environment, in particular the preservation or, as far as possible, the restoration of the purity of the air, water and soil, and the prevention or reduction of the harmful effects of noise,
…
(j) the preservation and modern development of a competitive economy that meets the requirements of the labour market, the supply needs of the population and the requirements of environmental protection; …“.
On the basis of this Spatial Planning Act, local authorities draw up land-use plans and development plans within their own areas of jurisdiction, which set out, in particular, the permitted uses of land and more detailed specifications for development (e.g. building height).
Finally: The principle of legality is, in itself, binding only on the executive (administration and the judiciary); however, it also has an indirect impact on the legislative process itself. This is because the Constitutional Court derives from Article 18(1) of the Federal Constitutional Act (B-VG) that the legislature is obliged to ensure that the executive is bound by statutory provisions that are sufficiently specific and linguistically comprehensible (further details on the requirement of specificity are explained in Lecture 40). A review of legislation in recent years shows that this constitutional mandate is being disregarded with increasing frequency ….
2. TO PUT IT IN A NUTSHELL
State executive power – comprising the administration and the judiciary – may only be exercised in accordance with the law. This principle of legality, enshrined in Article 18(1) of the Federal Constitutional Law (B-VG), is an essential feature of the fundamental principle of the rule of law. Indirectly, it also applies to the legislature, as it obliges it to enact provisions that are sufficiently specific and clearly comprehensible.
If your statutory rights are not being upheld in accordance with the law, we will be happy to assist you in enforcing them. Score points with us!
Written by:
SHMP Schwartz Huber-Medek Partner Rechtsanwälte GmbH
Hohenstaufengasse 7
A-1010 Vienna
tel: +43.1.513 50 050
fax: +43.1.513 50 05-50
office@shmp.at